MYSTAGOGY

The Weblog Of John Sanidopoulos

BannerFans.com
  • Home
  • ABOUT
  • SAINTS & FEASTS
  • RESOURCES
  • BOOKSTORE
  • DONATE
Loading...

MYSTAGOGY

MYSTAGOGY
My Photo
J.Sanidopoulos
This weblog offers insights and analysis on various matters of life and thought from a 21st century Orthodox Christian perspective, among other things.
View my complete profile
http://www.facebookloginhut.com/facebook-login/ http://www.facebookloginhut.com/facebook-login/

Enter your email address:

Delivered by FeedBurner

Support Mystagogy

Mystagogy relies on your financial support to continue and to expand. We hope you value what is offered here. If so, please show your support with either a one-time donation or a monthly subscription by clicking here: DONATE

Blog Archive

  • ►  2013 (362)
    • ►  June (36)
    • ►  May (71)
    • ►  April (67)
    • ►  March (77)
    • ►  February (9)
    • ►  January (102)
  • ►  2012 (1047)
    • ►  December (99)
    • ►  November (59)
    • ►  October (69)
    • ►  September (58)
    • ►  August (74)
    • ►  July (116)
    • ►  June (121)
    • ►  May (125)
    • ►  April (138)
    • ►  March (96)
    • ►  February (3)
    • ►  January (89)
  • ►  2011 (1427)
    • ►  December (60)
    • ►  November (65)
    • ►  October (84)
    • ►  September (63)
    • ►  August (107)
    • ►  July (40)
    • ►  June (133)
    • ►  May (161)
    • ►  April (198)
    • ►  March (174)
    • ►  February (161)
    • ►  January (181)
  • ►  2010 (2462)
    • ►  December (221)
    • ►  November (211)
    • ►  October (149)
    • ►  September (200)
    • ►  August (187)
    • ►  July (209)
    • ►  June (170)
    • ►  May (199)
    • ►  April (236)
    • ►  March (240)
    • ►  February (227)
    • ►  January (213)
  • ▼  2009 (874)
    • ►  December (160)
    • ►  November (124)
    • ►  October (140)
    • ▼  September (116)
      • Where Did ‘We’ Go?
      • Religious Right Should End 'Demonization' Of Polit...
      • The Story of a Turk Who "Fell In Love" With Hagia ...
      • Questions to Ponder From the Bible
      • Connecting Andy Warhol With His Byzantine Roots
      • Joy Behar Lashes Out On Ukrainian Orthodox Priest ...
      • Confession - Confessor - Confessing
      • "Transgression" In Rock and Roll According to Mari...
      • "Magic and Religion: Gods, Saints and Demons" exhi...
      • Center for Inquiry’s BLASPHEMY CONTEST
      • A Response to Moscow's Sad Claims of "Rank"
      • The Primacy of Constantinople in Relation to Russi...
      • Various Views on Fasting
      • New Tunnel in Istanbul Unearths 1,000 year-old Byz...
      • More on the Relationship Between Elder Paisios and...
      • The Repose of St. John the Theologian According to...
      • Unusual Phenomenon at Solovki Monastery
      • Unusual Celestial Event Over the Kursk Root Hermit...
      • 14 Schismatic Monks of Esphigmenou Convicted
      • Archbishop Ieronymos Cracking Down on Greedy Clerg...
      • Putin Bows to the Main Shrine of the Russian Orth...
      • A Question Concerning the Knowledge of God and Ort...
      • The Wonderworking Kursk Icon Returns Home
      • Protestant Views on Justification, Eternal Securit...
      • 'Last Ottoman' Dies in Istanbul
      • Pope Benedict XVI on Saint Symeon the New Theologi...
      • Journalist Who Asked "Is God Dead?" Has Died
      • The Last Days of Elder Tychon the Athonite: A Bles...
      • Three Dead End Approaches in Verifying God's Exist...
      • The American Ministry of Elder Joachim of St. Anne...
      • Elder Daniel Katounakiotis and the Deluded Monk
      • Counsel for Youth from Elder Daniel Katounakiotis
      • The Prophet Jonah in the Writings of the Church Fa...
      • Abkhazian Orthodox Seek Independence from Georgia
      • New Athos Monastery in Abkhazia
      • A LETTER OF CONSOLATION TO THE BEREAVED
      • Great Martyr Eustathios Plakidas With His Wife and...
      • Ecumenical Patriarch's Message for the End of Rama...
      • Fr, Moses Berry and the Film "God's Garden"
      • Beautiful Serbian Orthodox Songs
      • New Book on the Christology of Fr. John Romanides ...
      • Saint Ariadne of Phrygia
      • Frank Schaeffer Takes On the Religious Right
      • Recent Perspectives on the Reliability of the Gosp...
      • The "Kollyvades" Fathers of the Holy Mountain
      • Russian Priest and Father of 18 Children Decorated...
      • Consequentialism: the Moral Philosophy of the West...
      • Vandals Desecrate Orthodox Christian Cemetery in C...
      • Saint Euphemia's Conversation With Elder Paisios
      • Elder Arsenios the Cave-Dweller (1886-1983) with P...
      • Papoulakis: Saint Joachim of Vatopaidi (12)
      • Saint Niketas the Goth and Great Martyr
      • Mount Athos to be Featured In Dan Brown's "The Los...
      • The Miraculous Prozimi
      • The Cross – The Preserver of the Universe
      • The Orthodox Celebration of the Power of the Cross...
      • On the Two Accounts of the Discovery of the True C...
      • The Missionary Efforts of Metropolitan Nektarios o...
      • Homily on the Dedication of the Church of the Holy...
      • Testimony of an Orthodox Christian Who Became a Mu...
      • Papoulakis: Saint Joachim of Vatopaidi (11)
      • To Avoid Greed and Lust Avoid Temptation, says New...
      • An Orthodox Hymn For September 11th (9/11)?
      • Swine Flu in the Chalice?
      • Papoulakis: Saint Joachim of Vatopaidi (10)
      • Papoulakis: Saint Joachim of Vatopaidi (9)
      • The Emptiness of Buddhism
      • Panagia Plataniotissa: Sacred Shrines Which Honor ...
      • New Atheists vs. Framing Atheists: ID Perspective
      • Blood of St. Januarius Won't Be Kissed This Year B...
      • Truth or Hoax: Ossuary of James Going to Trial
      • Ochrid Tragedy Blamed on Madonna by Bulgarian Bish...
      • Panagia Katsimikados: Sacred Shrines Which Honor t...
      • On the Nativity of the Theotokos - Various Church ...
      • On the Nativity of the Theotokos - St. Andrew of C...
      • On The Nativity Of The Theotokos - By St. Dimitri ...
      • On Temptations, Sorrow and Despair
      • Saint John of Novgorod Receives Miraculous Aid fro...
      • An Illustrated Synaxarion For Children - "My Warri...
      • The Apostolic Testimony of Evodus Concerning the T...
      • Miracle at Chonai by Archangel Michael, Chief Comm...
      • So-Called "Expert" Congressman Can't Take the Heat...
      • Advice From Metropolitan of Rhodes Shows How Ecume...
      • Muslim Terrorists Use Remains of Byzantine Churche...
      • Turkish Film Takes Serious Look at Anti-Greek Riot...
      • Discovering the Greek Side of İstanbul
      • Russian Seminary Students Required to Reveal All I...
      • Bulgaria Recreates Orpheus’s Lyre
      • NIV Bible Changes on the Way
      • XVII International Ecumenical Conference on Orthod...
      • Augustine in Eastern and Western Tradition
      • "Signature in the Cell" on C-SPAN's BookTV This We...
      • Bulgarian Archaeologists Find Relics of Medieval S...
      • Ukrainian Theologian Threatens Ecumenical Patriarc...
      • Nearly 70% of Russians Approve of Introducing Orth...
      • Help Save Two Detained Muslim Converts To Christia...
      • The Changing Demographics of the West
      • The Human Body — Wired for Extremes: True Stories ...
      • Saint Anthimos Kourouklis, the Blind Ascetic of Ke...
      • Dervishes Dance on the Face of Christ: More Eviden...
      • Patriarch on Death List, Orthodox Fear Another Pog...
      • A Short History of the Illuminati
      • Lost Fragment of Codex Sinaiticus Discovered
      • The First Orthodox Monastery of New Zealand
      • Mount of St. Stephen of Perm
      • UOAC Official Request
      • Assyrian Orthodox Community Trying to Preserve Its...
      • 650 Pilgrims Prevented From Celebrating the Feast ...
      • An Icon of Saint Ephraim Preserved in the Fires of...
      • Schismatic Ukrainian Church Requests to Come Under...
      • Christianity Beyond A Religion
      • Monk to Teach Morality Through Online Game
      • A Lesson For Wives... (2)
      • Worshipping Among Stylites!
      • Patristic Testimony of the Prophetic Ministry of J...
      • Three Tips For Students Studying Evolution
    • ►  August (86)
    • ►  July (97)
    • ►  June (60)
    • ►  May (42)
    • ►  April (49)

Topics

  • Abortion (1)
  • Alexandros Papadiamandis (1)
  • Almsgiving (4)
  • America (156)
  • Angels (52)
  • Anglicans (3)
  • Annunciation (2)
  • Anthony the Great (3)
  • Anthropology (23)
  • Antiochian Archdiocese of America (10)
  • Apocrypha (1)
  • Apologetics (81)
  • Apostles and Early Church (164)
  • Art (40)
  • Athanasius the Great (3)
  • Atheism-Agnosticism-Skepticism (207)
  • Augustine of Hippo (4)
  • Balkans and Russia (61)
  • Basil the Great (3)
  • Bible (41)
  • Bible Difficulties (1)
  • Biblical and Christian Archaeology (11)
  • Biblical and Christian Archeology (94)
  • Biblical Criticism (30)
  • Bioethics (1)
  • Byzantine Music (1)
  • C.S. Lewis (2)
  • Calendar Issue (3)
  • Canon Law (36)
  • Catholicism and Papacy (158)
  • Celtic Saints (1)
  • Childless Mothers (1)
  • Christian Living (172)
  • Christology (63)
  • Church and Society (1)
  • Church History (50)
  • Climate Change (1)
  • Conspiracies (93)
  • Constantine the Great (5)
  • Coptic Church (44)
  • Cross (91)
  • Cults (83)
  • Cyril and Methodios (1)
  • Cyril Loukaris (1)
  • Cyril of Jerusalem (1)
  • Demetrios of Thessaloniki (2)
  • Demonology (7)
  • Desert Fathers (12)
  • Divine Liturgy (8)
  • Divorce (5)
  • Documentaries (9)
  • Dormition Fast (35)
  • Ecclesiology (86)
  • Ecumenical Patriarchate (158)
  • Ecumenical Synods (7)
  • Ecumenism (106)
  • Elder Aimilianos of Simonopetra (2)
  • Elder Cleopa of Romania (2)
  • Elder Ephraim Katounakiotis (2)
  • Elder Epiphanios Theodoropoulos (2)
  • Elder Eusebius Yiannakakis (1)
  • Elder Iakovos of Evia (1)
  • Elder Paisios the Athonite (34)
  • Elder Porphyrios (7)
  • Elder Sophrony of Essex (6)
  • Entrance of the Theotokos (2)
  • Ephraim of Nea Makri (1)
  • Ephraim the Syrian (2)
  • Eschatology/Death (181)
  • Ethical and Moral Issues (70)
  • Europe (85)
  • Events (14)
  • Family and Parish (81)
  • Famous People (6)
  • Fasting (5)
  • Feasts of the Church (95)
  • Fr. George Florovsky (4)
  • Fr. George Metallinos (1)
  • Fr. John Romanides (7)
  • Fr. Seraphim Rose (1)
  • Freemasonry (1)
  • Funny (48)
  • George the Great Martyr (6)
  • Globalization (1)
  • God (69)
  • Gothic and Horror (38)
  • Great Lent (9)
  • Great Lent and Holy Week (333)
  • Greece and Greeks (213)
  • Greek Archdiocese of America (GOA) (66)
  • Gregory of Nyssa (1)
  • Gregory Palamas (9)
  • Gregory the Theologian (2)
  • Hagia Sophia (7)
  • Halki Seminary (2)
  • Halloween (5)
  • Happiness (1)
  • Health (1)
  • Health and Creation (138)
  • Heresy (101)
  • Holidays (17)
  • Holy Light (1)
  • Holy Matrimony (2)
  • Holy Mysteries (Sacraments) (142)
  • Holy Unction (1)
  • Holy Week (27)
  • Homosexuality (2)
  • Iconography (292)
  • Isaac the Syrian (3)
  • John Chrysostom (6)
  • John Climacus (2)
  • John the Baptist (10)
  • Judging (1)
  • Justin Popovic (1)
  • Lay Holiness (2)
  • Literature (28)
  • Literature and Book Reviews (89)
  • Liturgics (93)
  • Logic / Reason (1)
  • Luke of Crimea (2)
  • Mariology (274)
  • Marital and Relationship Issues (97)
  • Maximus the Confessor (2)
  • Maximus the Greek (2)
  • Medieval History and Theology (58)
  • Meteora (3)
  • Metropolitan Hierotheos Vlachos (21)
  • Middle East (55)
  • Miracles (454)
  • Missions (105)
  • Modern Saints and Elders (536)
  • Modernity (30)
  • Monasticism (129)
  • Monk Moses the Athonite (6)
  • Moral Stories (2)
  • Moscow Patriarchate (1)
  • Mothers (2)
  • Mount Athos (312)
  • Movies (132)
  • Music (112)
  • My Family and Friends (25)
  • My Writings (1)
  • N.T. - Acts of the Apostles (2)
  • N.T. - Colossians (1)
  • N.T. - John (4)
  • N.T. - Luke (1)
  • N.T. - Mark (6)
  • N.T. - Matthew (4)
  • N.T. - Revelation (1)
  • N.T. 1 Corinthians (1)
  • N.T. 1 Timothy (1)
  • N.T. Hebrews (1)
  • N.T. Luke (3)
  • Nationalism (6)
  • Nativity and Theophany (234)
  • Nektarios of Aegina (6)
  • Neomartys Under Turks (11)
  • New England (19)
  • New Martyrs Under Turks (2)
  • New Testament (181)
  • New Testament Exegesis (7)
  • Newly-Revealed Saints (3)
  • Nicholas of Myra (8)
  • Nicolae Steinhardt (3)
  • Nikephoros the Leper (2)
  • Nikodemos the Hagiorite (2)
  • Nikolai Velimirovich (8)
  • O.T. - Genesis (1)
  • Old Testament (150)
  • Old Testament Exegesis (9)
  • Oriental Orthodox (2)
  • Orthodox Church In America (OCA) (13)
  • Orthodox Converts (101)
  • Orthodox Diaspora (10)
  • Orthodox Extremism (150)
  • Orthodox Theologians (66)
  • Orthodoxy (39)
  • Orthodoxy in Abkhazia (1)
  • Orthodoxy in Africa (64)
  • Orthodoxy in Albania (13)
  • Orthodoxy in America (142)
  • Orthodoxy in Armenia (18)
  • Orthodoxy in Asia (46)
  • Orthodoxy in Asia Minor (171)
  • Orthodoxy in Australia (6)
  • Orthodoxy in Bulgaria (99)
  • Orthodoxy in Crete (8)
  • Orthodoxy in Cyprus (100)
  • Orthodoxy in Czech Republic (1)
  • Orthodoxy in Estonia (3)
  • Orthodoxy in Ethiopia (8)
  • Orthodoxy in Finland (2)
  • Orthodoxy in France (1)
  • Orthodoxy in Georgia (71)
  • Orthodoxy in Germany (1)
  • Orthodoxy in Greece (457)
  • Orthodoxy In Holy Land (22)
  • Orthodoxy In Israel (140)
  • Orthodoxy in Italy (2)
  • Orthodoxy in Kazakhstan (1)
  • Orthodoxy in Latin America (2)
  • Orthodoxy in Lebanon (1)
  • Orthodoxy in Macedonia (16)
  • Orthodoxy in Mainland Greece (6)
  • Orthodoxy in Moldava (4)
  • Orthodoxy in Poland (2)
  • Orthodoxy in Romania (87)
  • Orthodoxy in Russia (416)
  • Orthodoxy in Serbia (140)
  • Orthodoxy in Syria (7)
  • Orthodoxy in the Cyclades (4)
  • Orthodoxy in the Dodecanese (12)
  • Orthodoxy in the Ionian Islands (3)
  • Orthodoxy in the Saronic Islands (2)
  • Orthodoxy in Thessaloniki (2)
  • Orthodoxy in Ukraine (60)
  • Orthodoxy in Uzbekistan (2)
  • Orthodoxy in Western Europe (73)
  • Ottoman Occupation (7)
  • Paganism and the New Age Movement (98)
  • Panteleimon the Martyr (1)
  • Paranormal and the Occult (198)
  • Pascha and the Pentecostarion (256)
  • Patriarchate of Alexandria (1)
  • Patriarchate of Antioch (5)
  • Patriarchate of Russia (1)
  • Patristic Writings (16)
  • Patristics (325)
  • Pentecostalism (4)
  • Personhood (1)
  • Philanthropy (11)
  • Philosophy (82)
  • Photios Kontoglou (3)
  • Photis Kontoglou (1)
  • Pneumatology (3)
  • Podcast (2)
  • Politics (143)
  • Polls (2)
  • Pop Culture (54)
  • Postmodernism (6)
  • Prayer (4)
  • Prayer / Fasting / Alms (159)
  • Priesthood (10)
  • Prison Ministry (6)
  • Prophecies (56)
  • Protestantism (119)
  • Psychology (73)
  • Religion (85)
  • Religion: Buddhism (19)
  • Religion: Hinduism (41)
  • Religion: Islam (185)
  • Religion: Jews and Judaism (58)
  • Repentance and Confession (3)
  • Roman (Byzantine) Empire (202)
  • Romiosini (35)
  • Russian Orthodox Church Outside of Russia (ROCOR) (6)
  • Saint Nicholas (4)
  • Saints (847)
  • Saints of Africa (1)
  • Saints of America (3)
  • Saints of Crete (8)
  • Saints of Georgia (4)
  • Saints of Ionian Islands (8)
  • Saints of Lesvos (1)
  • Saints of Mainland Greece (16)
  • Saints of Mount Athos (9)
  • Saints of Patmos (1)
  • Saints of Romania (3)
  • Saints of Russia (9)
  • Saints of Scotland (2)
  • Saints of Serbia (4)
  • Saints of the Cyclades (2)
  • Saints of the Dodecanese (2)
  • Saints of the Holy Lnd (1)
  • Saints of Ukraine (5)
  • Scandal (56)
  • Science (2)
  • Science-Intelligent Design-Darwinism (249)
  • Secularism (97)
  • Seraphim of Sarov (2)
  • Sexual and Gender Issues (107)
  • Shrines and Relics (564)
  • Soteriology (80)
  • Spiritual Fatherhood (4)
  • Spirituality (221)
  • Sports (20)
  • sShrines and Relics (1)
  • St. Cyril Loukaris (1)
  • St. John of Kronstadt (1)
  • st. John the Baptist (2)
  • St. John the Russian (1)
  • St. Luke of Simferopol (1)
  • St. Maximus the Confessor (1)
  • St. Nektarios (2)
  • St. Nikodemos the Hagiorite (1)
  • St. Nikolai Velimirovich (3)
  • Strange (37)
  • Sts. Bartholomew and John (1)
  • Substance Issues (14)
  • Symeon the New Theologian (3)
  • Television and Media (45)
  • Television and Media. (1)
  • Theodicy/Evil/Suffering (84)
  • Theology (98)
  • Theophilos of Campania (1)
  • Theotokos Icons (19)
  • Tradition (62)
  • Triodion (8)
  • UFO's and Alien Life (2)
  • Uniates (6)
  • v (1)
  • Vice and Sin (111)
  • video (1)
  • Videos (80)
  • Violence-Crime-Persecution (161)
  • Virtue (118)
  • Youth Ministry (107)

Subscribe To

Posts
Atom
Posts
Comments
Atom
Comments

Visitor Map
Create your own visitor map!

Friday, September 25, 2009

Protestant Views on Justification, Eternal Security and Salvation Outside the Church: An Orthodox Biblical Response


Unlike Martin Luther who was offended by the New Testament Book of James because it "contradicted" his Sola Fidei (faith alone) doctrine - an apostolic book which dared not to separate the faith of a believer from the manifestation of one's faith, which is "works" - the Orthodox Church has been faithful to the apostolic tradition for 2000 years. It never took part in the vain debate of the Reformers of the 16th century who over-reacted against the abuses of Papal Rome by separating faith and works because it never had to. Biblical and Patristic faith comprehends all of life and always is dynamically manifested through the way we live, talk, walk and think. Only by our thoughts and our deeds can we be separated from Satan, whose faith in Jesus surpasses our own. The mind of the Church has always been that those who seek to separate faith from works only reveal their own wickedness, who do not want to manifest their faith with their deeds. And it is for this reason that Jesus says repeatedly that it is by our deeds, which manifest our faith, that we will be judged (Lk. 3:7-14; Mt. 7:21-23; Matt. 25:31-46; etc). And though our faith justifies us (Rom. 3:28), what Paul describes is a living faith that is manifestated by a righteous life, defeat of Satan's power over our lives, growth in the virtues, and a progress through the purification of the heart unto an illumination of the Holy Spirit which is perfection in Christ (Matt. 5:20; Rev. 14:12; Heb. 11:4,8; Is. 58:5-7).

Furthermore, justification is not a legal acquital before God, but part of a covenant relationship with Him Who having fulfilled the requirements of the Law and defeated death by His death has raised us to new life through "water (baptism) and the Spirit" (Rom. 6:4; Jn. 3:5). Christ came to establish a visible Church (Matt. 16:18) to gather all those destined for condemnation, like Noah did in the Ark. He did not come to give us the Scriptures, but to write the law of God within our hearts through the acquisition of the Holy Spirit (Jer. 31:33; Jn 8:7). It is the Holy Spirit which unites the visible Church into a living and organic Body of Christ of diverse spiritual gifts. We are initiated into the Body of Christ through baptism and the eucharist, since without the reception of the Body and Blood of Christ we can have no part in Christ (Jn. 6:53-58). Through the purification of one's heart and mind and the reception of the Mysteries (Sacraments) of the Church the Lord through His Holy Spirit heals us wounded by our passions and sins (all this is revealed in Lk. 10:34), and we become a temple of the Holy Spirit by God's grace and mercy, unworthy though we be.

Orthodox Christians simply leave all judgement to God and dare not judge someone's salvation lest they also be judged (Matt. 7:1), and they by no means judge themselves either (to hell or heaven). All judgement is left to the Lord, and it is up to us to always be ready and be watchful, lest we be "cut off" (Rom 11:22; Matt. 25:13) - we are to be always faithful in a dynamic way and be concerned with this alone. Our love for God is proved in how we keep His commandments (John 14:21). If the Apostle Paul considered himself the greatest of sinners in his great humility (1 Tim. 1:15; Phil. 3:12-14; Rom 7:15-19), even though he had attained great spiritual heights by the grace of God and was a visionary of the uncreated glory of God in the third heaven, then we also ought to imitate him (1 Cor. 11:1) and dare not condemn anyone but ourselves. God alone knows the heart and He has made clear that "My ways are not your ways" (Is. 55:8). A true Christian tries to imitate the selfless love of Christ who condemned Himself to death to save us wretches, as did the Prophet Moses who preferred to lose his own salvation so that the people of Israel would be saved (Ex. 32:30-33), and its for Moses' humility (Ex. 4:10; Num 12:3) that God chose him and exalted him. This was also repeated by the Apostle Paul (Rom 9:1-5). Like the Prophet Isaiah, the nearer we come to the glory of God the more we feel the need to condemn ourselves rather than others (Is. 6:5). Therefore, we repeat with the Apostle Paul: "It is a very small thing that I should be judged by you or by a human court. For I know of nothing against myself, yet I am not justified by this; but He who judges me is the Lord. Therefore judge nothing before the time, until the Lord comes, who will both bring to light the hidden things of darkness and reveal the counsels of the hearts. Then each one's praise will come from God." (1 Cor. 4:3-5). And again: "For if we would judge ourselves, we should not be judged. But when we are judged, we are chastened of the Lord, that we should not be condemned with the world." (1 Cor. 11:31-32).
Tweet
Share on Tumblr
Posted by J.Sanidopoulos at 11:49 AM
Email ThisBlogThis!Share to TwitterShare to Facebook
Labels: Protestantism, Soteriology
Reactions: 

No comments:

Post a Comment

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.

Newer Post Older Post Home
Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom)
Related Posts with Thumbnails